Beggars

William Wordsworth's Beggars

William Wordsworth’s Beggars (1802) is a deceptively simple poem that encapsulates the Romantic fascination with poverty, beauty, and the supernatural. At first glance, it appears to be a straightforward encounter with two impoverished figures—a majestic beggar woman and two playful boys—but beneath its surface lies a meditation on perception, reality, and the transient nature of human suffering. This essay will explore the poem’s historical and cultural context, its rich literary devices, its thematic concerns, and its emotional resonance. Additionally, we will consider Wordsworth’s broader poetic philosophy, drawing connections to his other works and the Romantic movement at large.

Historical and Cultural Context

Wordsworth composed Beggars during a period of profound social upheaval in England. The late 18th and early 19th centuries saw the rise of industrialization, which displaced rural communities and exacerbated poverty. The Poor Laws of the time were notoriously harsh, and begging was both a visible social ill and a moral dilemma for the privileged classes. Wordsworth, deeply influenced by the democratic ideals of the French Revolution, often turned his poetic gaze toward marginalized figures—shepherds, leech gatherers, and, in this case, beggars.

The poem also reflects the Romantic era’s fascination with the exotic and the sublime. The beggar woman’s "Egyptian brown" face and regal bearing evoke distant lands and ancient warrior queens, suggesting that even in destitution, there is dignity and grandeur. This aligns with Wordsworth’s belief in the inherent nobility of the rural poor, a theme he explores in Lyrical Ballads (1798), where he elevates ordinary lives to the level of poetic significance.

Literary Devices and Imagery

1. Vivid Visual Imagery

Wordsworth employs striking visual descriptions to create an almost painterly effect. The woman’s "long drab-colour’d Cloak" and snow-white cap contrast sharply with her "Egyptian brown" face, suggesting a figure both weathered and majestic. The boys, meanwhile, are depicted with "a rimless crown / With leaves of laurel stuck about," evoking classical imagery of youthful innocence and even divine favor.

2. Simile and Hyperbole

The speaker’s initial description of the woman borders on hyperbole:

"Fit person was she for a Queen, / To head those ancient Amazonian files: / Or ruling Bandit’s Wife, among the Grecian Isles."

These similes elevate her beyond the station of a mere beggar, transforming her into a mythic figure. The comparison to Amazons and Grecian bandits suggests a wild, untamed nobility, reinforcing Wordsworth’s Romantic idealization of the marginalized.

3. Juxtaposition of Beauty and Suffering

The speaker acknowledges the woman’s sorrows—"Pouring out sorrows like a sea"—yet is struck by her beauty: "a Weed of glorious feature!" This oxymoronic phrase encapsulates Wordsworth’s belief that beauty and suffering often coexist, a theme echoed in The Solitary Reaper and Resolution and Independence.

4. Symbolism of the Butterfly and Flowers

The boys chasing a "crimson butterfly" symbolize fleeting joy and the ephemeral nature of childhood. The taller boy’s hat, "wreath’d round with yellow flow’rs," suggests a natural crown, reinforcing the idea that beauty persists even in poverty. The butterfly, a traditional symbol of the soul, may also hint at the spectral nature of the encounter.

5. Dialogue and Ambiguity

The boys’ insistence that their mother is dead introduces an eerie ambiguity. Is the woman a ghost? A figment of the speaker’s imagination? Or are the boys lying? Wordsworth leaves this unresolved, heightening the poem’s dreamlike quality.

Themes

1. The Sublime in Poverty

Wordsworth does not merely pity the beggars; he finds in them a kind of sublimity. The woman’s grandeur and the boys’ vitality suggest that poverty does not strip individuals of their dignity. This aligns with Edmund Burke’s Philosophical Enquiry into the Sublime and Beautiful (1757), where the sublime is linked to awe-inspiring, even terrifying beauty.

2. Perception vs. Reality

The poem blurs the line between reality and illusion. The speaker is certain he has just given alms to the boys’ mother, yet they claim she has been dead for years. This ambiguity invites readers to question whether the woman was a ghost, a metaphor for lingering social ills, or a projection of the speaker’s guilt.

3. Transience and Memory

The ephemeral nature of the encounter—like the butterfly the boys chase—reflects Wordsworth’s preoccupation with memory and fleeting moments of insight. The poem captures a transient experience that lingers in the mind, much like the "spots of time" he describes in The Prelude.

4. Childhood and Innocence

The boys’ carefree play contrasts with their sudden shift to begging, mirroring the precariousness of childhood in impoverished conditions. Yet their immediate return to play suggests resilience, a theme Wordsworth explores in We Are Seven and Ode: Intimations of Immortality.

Emotional Impact

The poem’s emotional power lies in its unresolved tension between beauty and sorrow. The woman’s suffering is palpable, yet her majesty lingers in the imagination. The boys’ laughter and denial of their mother’s death create an unsettling dissonance—are they unaware, in denial, or supernatural beings? This ambiguity leaves the reader haunted, much like the speaker.

Comparative Analysis

1. Wordsworth’s The Old Cumberland Beggar

In The Old Cumberland Beggar, Wordsworth presents another dignified beggar, arguing that society has a moral duty to care for him. Unlike Beggars, however, that poem lacks supernatural ambiguity, focusing instead on social critique.

2. Coleridge’s The Rime of the Ancient Mariner

The spectral quality of the beggar woman recalls Coleridge’s ghostly figures. Both poets use the uncanny to explore guilt, charity, and the unknown.

3. John Clare’s The Gypsy’s Camp

Clare, like Wordsworth, depicts beggars with sympathy, though his approach is more grounded in realism, lacking Wordsworth’s mythic overtones.

Philosophical and Biographical Insights

Wordsworth’s own encounters with beggars during his walks in the Lake District likely inspired this poem. His belief in the "wise passiveness" of nature—that profound truths emerge in quiet observation—shapes the poem’s meditative tone.

Philosophically, the poem aligns with Rousseau’s idea of the "noble savage"—the notion that those untouched by civilization possess innate virtue. The beggar woman, though poor, commands respect, while the boys’ natural joy contrasts with societal corruption.

Conclusion

Beggars is a masterful exploration of beauty, suffering, and the liminal spaces between reality and illusion. Through vivid imagery, ambiguous dialogue, and rich symbolism, Wordsworth elevates a mundane encounter into a meditation on human dignity and the mysteries of perception. The poem’s emotional resonance lies in its unresolved tension—between the woman’s majesty and her sorrow, the boys’ innocence and their possible deceit. In true Romantic fashion, Wordsworth finds the extraordinary in the ordinary, leaving readers to ponder the deeper truths hidden within fleeting moments.

In an age where poverty was often met with disdain, Wordsworth’s Beggars stands as a testament to the enduring power of empathy and the sublime in the most unexpected places.

This text was generated by AI and is for reference only. Learn more