It Couldn't be Done

Edgar A. Guest's It Couldn't be Done

Edgar A. Guest's poem It Couldn't Be Done exemplifies his characteristic optimism and celebration of perseverance. Known as the "People's Poet," Guest often wrote verses that inspired everyday individuals to confront life's challenges with courage and determination. This poem, structured in three stanzas of rhyming couplets, serves as both a narrative and an exhortation, urging readers to overcome doubt and fear through effort and optimism. The poem’s accessible language and rhythm contribute to its motivational tone, making it a timeless ode to human resilience.

Analysis of Themes

The central theme of the poem is perseverance in the face of doubt. Guest contrasts the skepticism of naysayers with the protagonist's resolve to attempt the seemingly impossible. This theme is universal, resonating with anyone who has faced challenges or skepticism. The repeated use of "it couldn't be done" underscores the prevalence of doubt, but the protagonist's actions demonstrate that effort, rather than certainty of success, is the key to achievement.

A secondary theme is the power of optimism. The protagonist approaches his task with a "grin" and a song, suggesting that a positive attitude is not only a source of personal strength but also a form of defiance against negativity. This aligns with Guest's broader philosophy that resilience and cheerfulness are integral to overcoming obstacles.

Analysis of Literary Devices

1. Repetition

The phrase "it couldn't be done" is repeated throughout the poem, emphasizing the opposition faced by the protagonist. This repetition mirrors the persistence of societal doubt, which the protagonist counters with his unyielding determination.

2. Alliteration

Guest employs alliteration to create rhythm and reinforce key ideas, as seen in phrases like "bit of a grin" and "tackle the thing." These linguistic flourishes enhance the poem’s musicality, making it more engaging and memorable.

3. Imagery

The imagery in the poem is straightforward, reflecting its universal appeal. Phrases such as "he took off his coat and he took off his hat" depict the protagonist’s readiness to work, while "the dangers that wait to assail you" evokes the obstacles that one must overcome.

4. Tone and Mood

The tone of the poem is unambiguously optimistic, and the mood it creates is one of inspiration and encouragement. Guest’s use of colloquial language and conversational style lends the poem a relatable, uplifting quality.

5. Structure and Form

The poem's structure—three quatrains of rhyming couplets—lends it a steady rhythm that mirrors the steady effort of the protagonist. The consistent rhyme scheme (AABB) contributes to the poem's sing-song quality, reinforcing its motivational message.

Line-by-Line Interpretation

• Stanza 1: The first stanza introduces the central conflict: the doubt of others versus the protagonist’s determination. The phrase "with the trace of a grin" signifies that even in the face of uncertainty, the protagonist maintains a positive outlook, which he bolsters by singing as he works. This stanza establishes the triumphant conclusion: "and he did it."

• Stanza 2: The second stanza repeats the narrative with minor variations, emphasizing action over doubt. The protagonist’s readiness to "take off his coat and…hat" symbolizes his preparedness and commitment. This stanza strengthens the idea that success begins with the first step, despite others’ disbelief.

• Stanza 3: The final stanza shifts focus from the individual protagonist to a broader audience. Guest universalizes the lesson, addressing "thousands" of skeptics and urging readers to adopt the same attitude of cheerful resolve. The repetition of "buckle in with a bit of a grin" serves as a refrain, leaving the reader with a clear motivational takeaway.

Conclusion

It Couldn't Be Done by Edgar A. Guest is a quintessential example of motivational poetry, blending simple language with profound themes of perseverance and optimism. Its enduring appeal lies in its universal message: skepticism and obstacles are inevitable, but success is attainable through effort and a positive mindset. Guest’s deft use of repetition, alliteration, and rhythm makes the poem both accessible and inspirational, ensuring its place as a beloved piece of literature that continues to encourage readers to tackle the impossible.