My own heart let me more have pity on

Gerard Manley Hopkins's My own heart let me more have pity on

Gerard Manley Hopkins' sonnet "My own heart let me more have pity on" represents one of the most profound poetic explorations of psychological turmoil and spiritual redemption in Victorian literature. Composed during what scholars identify as Hopkins' "terrible sonnets" period (approximately 1885-1886), this work emerges from a time of profound personal crisis for the Jesuit priest and poet. While teaching classics at University College Dublin, Hopkins experienced a debilitating depression, spiritual desolation, and creative frustration that manifested in a series of intensely personal sonnets. This particular poem stands as a powerful testament to the poet's struggle for self-forgiveness and his attempt to reconcile his psychological suffering with his religious faith.

This analysis will examine the complex interplay between Hopkins' innovative poetic techniques and the profound psychological and theological dimensions of the sonnet. Through close textual analysis, historical contextualization, and consideration of Hopkins' unique aesthetic philosophy, we will illuminate how this deceptively simple fourteen-line poem encapsulates the poet's revolutionary approach to language, his distinctive religious sensibility, and his penetrating insights into the human psyche. Far from being merely a personal document of suffering, "My own heart let me more have pity on" offers a paradigmatic example of how poetic form can embody spiritual and psychological content, creating a work that resonates across time and speaks to universal human experiences of despair, self-recrimination, and the difficult path toward inner peace.

Historical and Biographical Context

To fully appreciate the significance of "My own heart let me more have pity on," we must situate it within Hopkins' life and the broader Victorian cultural milieu. Born in 1844 to a High Anglican family, Hopkins converted to Roman Catholicism in 1866 under the influence of John Henry Newman, a decision that caused considerable familial strain. His subsequent entry into the Jesuit order in 1868 represented an even more radical break with his background. After burning his early poems upon entering the novitiate—believing poetry incompatible with religious devotion—Hopkins eventually returned to writing, encouraged by his superior who suggested poetry might serve divine purposes.

By the mid-1880s, when this sonnet was likely composed, Hopkins found himself in Ireland, isolated from his native England during a period of heightened Anglo-Irish tensions. His teaching duties at University College Dublin provided little intellectual stimulation, and his poetic innovations remained largely unrecognized during his lifetime. This professional frustration, combined with bouts of severe depression, created what biographer Robert Bernard Martin terms "a dark night of the soul"—a spiritual crisis wherein Hopkins felt abandoned by God despite his religious devotion.

The "terrible sonnets" (or "dark sonnets") emerged from this crucible of suffering. Unlike his earlier nature poems celebrating the divine "inscape" (Hopkins' term for the unique essence of things), these later works turn inward, exploring spiritual desolation with unflinching honesty. "My own heart let me more have pity on" represents a pivotal moment in this sequence, as Hopkins begins to move from despair toward a tentative self-compassion and renewed spiritual hope.

This biographical context illuminates why the poem's concern with self-forgiveness carries such weight. For Hopkins, a man devoted to religious self-discipline and self-abnegation, acknowledging his own suffering and advocating self-compassion represented not mere psychological self-help but a profound theological reorientation. The poem thus operates simultaneously as personal therapy, spiritual exercise, and aesthetic innovation.

Formal Analysis: Structure and Technique

"My own heart let me more have pity on" adheres to the sonnet form, yet Hopkins transforms this traditional structure through his distinctive "sprung rhythm" and idiosyncratic syntax. The poem follows a Petrarchan sonnet structure with an octave (first eight lines) and sestet (final six lines), divided by a volta or turn that shifts from problem to resolution. However, Hopkins' formal innovations create a dynamic tension between traditional form and revolutionary technique.

The octave presents the speaker's predicament: his inability to show compassion toward himself and the resulting psychological torment. The sestet offers a potential resolution through self-address and the possibility of divine grace appearing unexpectedly. This structural movement from problem to partial resolution mirrors the psychological journey from self-torment to tentative self-acceptance.

Hopkins' famous "sprung rhythm"—his metrical innovation emphasizing stressed syllables rather than traditional iambic patterns—creates a linguistic intensity that embodies the psychological struggle described. Consider the opening line: "My own heart let me more have pity on; let." The irregular stress patterns, combined with the caesura (pause) after "on," create a halting rhythm that mimics the difficulty of self-compassion. The enjambment between lines one and two ("let / Me live") further enacts this hesitation, as if the speaker must gather courage to continue his plea for self-kindness.

Hopkins' compression of language—evident in coinages like "Betweenpie" and the truncated "s" in "'s not wrung"—creates a dense linguistic texture that demands active reader participation. This linguistic density serves not mere stylistic ornamentation but rather embodies the poem's thematic concern with psychological complexity. Just as the reader must work to unpack Hopkins' compressed language, so the speaker struggles to disentangle his self-critical thoughts.

Particularly striking is Hopkins' use of internal repetition, especially in the phrase "this tormented mind / With this tormented mind tormenting yet." The triple repetition of forms of "torment" creates a linguistic loop that enacts the cyclical nature of rumination and self-criticism. Similarly, the repetition in "thirst can find / Thirst's all-in-all in all a world of wet" creates a paradoxical sense of abundance (water) that fails to satisfy genuine need (thirst)—a perfect metaphor for the speaker's inability to find comfort despite his spiritual resources.

Imagery and Metaphor

The sonnet's imagery system revolves around a series of contrasting sensory experiences that illuminate the speaker's psychological state. The octave employs predominantly tactile and visual imagery associated with deprivation: "groping," "comfortless," "blind / Eyes in their dark," and "thirst." These sensory metaphors establish the speaker's condition as one of profound disorientation and unsatisfied need. Particularly powerful is the extended metaphor of the blind person searching for daylight or the thirsty person surrounded by undrinkable water—both capturing the futility of the speaker's self-tormenting mental patterns.

The sestet transitions to more expansive imagery, culminating in the remarkable final image: "as skies / Betweenpie mountains — lights a lovely mile." This unexpected natural imagery introduces elements of space, light, and beauty previously absent from the poem. The coined term "Betweenpie" creates a visual impression of mountains partially framing a strip of sky, suggesting limited but genuine illumination. This image of natural beauty breaking through between confining elements perfectly captures the poem's psychological movement toward openness and possibility.

Hopkins' imagery also carries theological significance. The "blind / Eyes in their dark" evoke biblical metaphors of spiritual blindness, while the final image of unexpected light recalls divine illumination. Similarly, the address to "Soul, self; come, poor Jackself" introduces the intimate, colloquial "Jackself" as a term for the speaker's essential being, reflecting Hopkins' interest in the individual's unique essence or "inscape."

Thematic Analysis

Self-Division and Inner Dialogue

Central to the poem is the theme of self-division—the speaker's consciousness split between the tormenting and tormented aspects of himself. This psychological fragmentation appears immediately in the opening address to "My own heart" and continues throughout the poem as the speaker addresses himself in the second person. The poem's most striking moment of self-division comes in the ninth line: "Soul, self; come, poor Jackself, I do advise / You." Here the speaker multiplies self-references, creating a complex inner dialogue between different aspects of his psyche.

This fragmentation reflects both psychological insights into depression's self-critical nature and theological concerns about human division from God. For Hopkins as a Jesuit priest, psychological wholeness remained inseparable from spiritual integration. The poem's movement toward self-compassion thus carries theological implications, suggesting that reconciliation with oneself parallels reconciliation with God.

Spiritual Desolation and Consolation

The sonnet navigates between what Ignatian spirituality (central to Jesuit training) terms "desolation" and "consolation"—states of spiritual emptiness and fulfillment. The octave portrays classic spiritual desolation: the inability to find comfort or meaning despite effort. The repeated "tormented" and the futile "groping round my comfortless" evoke the dark night of the soul tradition in Christian mysticism, wherein spiritual progress paradoxically involves periods of apparent divine absence.

The sestet introduces the possibility of consolation, though notably not through the speaker's effort but through divine initiative: "at God knows when to God knows what." This Ignatian surrender to divine timing suggests that the solution to spiritual desolation comes not through more intense striving but through acceptance and openness. The poem's final image of unexpected light "Betweenpie mountains" perfectly captures the Ignatian understanding of consolation as divine grace appearing in moments of receptivity rather than achievement.

Self-Compassion as Spiritual Practice

Perhaps the most radical aspect of the sonnet is its framing of self-compassion as spiritual virtue rather than self-indulgence. For a Victorian Jesuit like Hopkins, schooled in ascetic self-denial, the command to "let me more have pity on" his own heart represents a profound spiritual reorientation. The sonnet argues implicitly that endless self-criticism ("this tormented mind / With this tormented mind tormenting yet") proves not only psychologically destructive but spiritually counterproductive.

By advising himself to "call off thoughts awhile / Elsewhere" and "leave comfort root-room," Hopkins suggests that spiritual progress requires periods of mental rest and self-compassion. This insight anticipates modern psychological understandings of rumination and self-criticism as maintaining rather than resolving depressive states. More radically, it suggests that divine grace operates not through continuous self-scrutiny but through moments of acceptance and mental quietude: "let joy size / At God knows when to God knows what."

Linguistic Innovation and "Inscape"

Hopkins' distinctive linguistic style in this sonnet exemplifies his theory of "inscape"—his term for the unique inner pattern or essence of each thing. For Hopkins, poetic language should capture not generic descriptions but the specific, essential qualities of experience. We see this commitment to linguistic specificity throughout the poem, from the compressed "comfortless" to the coined "Betweenpie" to the personified "poor Jackself."

Particularly notable is Hopkins' use of unexpected verb forms: "let joy size" transforms "size" from noun to verb, suggesting joy's gradual expansion. Similarly, the inversion "whose smile / 's not wrung" creates a compression that emphasizes the contrast between forced and natural happiness. These linguistic innovations serve Hopkins' theological aesthetics, wherein language must be constantly renewed to capture authentic experience rather than conventional pieties.

The poem's famous final image—"as skies / Betweenpie mountains — lights a lovely mile"—perfectly exemplifies Hopkins' linguistic philosophy. The coined "Betweenpie" creates a visual compression that captures exactly how mountains frame a strip of sky. The verb "lights" carries both illumination and lightening of weight, suggesting both visual brightness and emotional relief. This precise, compressed language creates what Hopkins termed "instress"—the energy that makes inscape perceptible to others.

Comparative Readings

Hopkins' sonnet resonates with other works in both the Victorian and metaphysical traditions. The poem's self-division and psychological introspection recall John Donne's Holy Sonnets, particularly "Batter my heart, three-personed God," with its similarly conflicted speaker torn between divine aspiration and human limitation. Like Donne, Hopkins creates dramatic tension through direct address and psychological paradox.

Within the Victorian context, Hopkins' work contrasts revealingly with Tennyson's more conventionally metrical exploration of religious doubt in "In Memoriam." Where Tennyson's grief and questioning unfold in measured quatrains, Hopkins' spiritual crisis erupts in compressed, idiosyncratic language that fractures conventional forms while maintaining their underlying structure. This formal innovation parallels Hopkins' position as both orthodox Catholic and radical poetic innovator.

The sonnet also anticipates modernist psychological exploration. T.S. Eliot's fragmented consciousness in "The Waste Land" and later explorations of spiritual desolation in "Four Quartets" develop terrain that Hopkins first mapped in the terrible sonnets. Hopkins' innovative use of musical effects, compressed syntax, and psychological immediacy established techniques that would become central to modernist poetics.

Reception and Influence

"My own heart let me more have pity on" remained unpublished during Hopkins' lifetime, appearing only after his death when his friend Robert Bridges published his collected works in 1918. Initial reception focused primarily on Hopkins' metrical innovations rather than his psychological insights, with early critics often treating the "terrible sonnets" as technically interesting but thematically limited personal documents.

More recent scholarship has recognized the profound psychological sophistication of these late poems. Modern critics like Helen Vendler have identified Hopkins as anticipating psychological understandings of depression and self-compassion that would only be scientifically articulated decades later. Similarly, theological readings by critics like Rowan Williams have highlighted how Hopkins' poetry embodies rather than merely describes spiritual experience, creating what Williams terms "sacramental language."

Hopkins' influence extends beyond literary criticism into contemporary poetry. Seamus Heaney explicitly acknowledged his debt to Hopkins' sonic innovations and compressed diction, while Geoffrey Hill's religious poetry similarly explores the relationship between linguistic density and spiritual experience. Even poets working outside explicitly religious traditions, like Sylvia Plath, echo Hopkins' psychological intensity and his creation of language under extreme emotional pressure.

Conclusion

"My own heart let me more have pity on" stands as one of Gerard Manley Hopkins' most profound achievements, seamlessly integrating formal innovation, psychological insight, and spiritual struggle. Through his revolutionary "sprung rhythm," compressed diction, and striking imagery, Hopkins creates a poem that does not merely describe but enacts the process of moving from self-torment toward tentative self-acceptance and renewed spiritual hope.

What makes this sonnet particularly significant is its radical reframing of self-compassion as spiritual virtue rather than self-indulgence. For a Victorian Jesuit writing in a cultural context that often valorized stoic self-denial, Hopkins' gentle instruction to show pity toward his own heart represents a profound counter-cultural statement. This insight—that endless self-criticism proves not only psychologically destructive but spiritually counterproductive—anticipates contemporary psychological understandings while remaining rooted in Hopkins' distinctive theological vision.

The poem's final image of unexpected light appearing "Betweenpie mountains" offers no facile resolution to spiritual struggle but rather a genuine hope grounded in acceptance of limitation. The "lovely mile" of illuminated sky suggests not complete transformation but meaningful partial vision—a realistic spiritual consolation that acknowledges continued constraint while affirming genuine beauty. In this balanced vision, neither dismissing suffering nor surrendering to despair, Hopkins offers a lasting contribution to our understanding of both psychological resilience and spiritual authenticity.

Through this remarkable sonnet, Hopkins demonstrates how poetic form can embody rather than merely describe spiritual and psychological experience. His revolutionary language creates not abstract doctrine but lived experience on the page, inviting readers across time to recognize their own struggles in his precisely rendered words. In an age increasingly attentive to mental health and spiritual authenticity, Hopkins' voice speaks with renewed relevance, reminding us that self-compassion may be not self-indulgence but the necessary ground for genuine spiritual and psychological growth.