A quiet notice V2Melody closes at midnight on , Spanish time.

Closes

A note from Richard

V2Melody will close at midnight on 20 January 2028

This site has been a retirement project in musical poetry: poems chosen with care and set to music, offered freely for as long as it felt right to keep the garden open.

The work no longer holds the place it once did in my life. I have gone as far with it as I wish to go. Like a sand mandala, it was made to be completed and then released. I am not attached to its permanence, and I do not believe any of it needs to last beyond the time it was given. The poems were already here before I arrived and began to experiment with them. They will still be here when these musical experiments, and indeed myself, have been swept away, like the sand of a mandala. Nothing has been lost.

I want a simpler end to my life, days of simple love and enjoyment with my wonderful wife of 20 years. The work of maintaining a server, the monitoring, and the residual obligations that come with keeping a site alive no longer fit that life.

From 4 November 2026 I will not be adding new poems or musical poems to the site.

The experimental music I am making now is on my Suno profile. Those pieces stay there, and are not added to this site.

Until midnight on 20 January 2028, Spanish time, everything remains available exactly as it is. That is when my VPS server contract comes to an end, and it will not be renewed. After that, the server will be switched off and the site will disappear.

The Mandala Is Finished explains this more fully.

Thank you to anyone who found a poem, a track, or a quiet moment here.

The pleasure was in the making.

Richard

Home › Glossary › Letter E

Evaluative song

Form
Pronunciation

Understanding ARPABET Pronunciation

Want to hear it? Click the Listen button to hear the browser speak the word using text-to-speech!

The pronunciation guide uses the ARPABET phonetic system—the same system used in speech recognition and text-to-speech applications.

Vowel Examples:
AE1 = cat, bat
EH1 = bed, head
IY1 = see, me
OW1 = go, boat
UW1 = boot, do
Stress Numbers:
0 = no stress (unstressed)
1 = primary stress (loud)
2 = secondary stress (medium)
Example:
AH0 TH IY1 N AH0
= a-THEE-na (Athena)

The stressed syllable (marked with 1) is pronounced louder and clearer than others.

Quick Definition

A lyric poem that assesses, judges, or critically examines its subject matter

Detailed Definition
Evaluative song is a lyric poem that assesses, judges, or critically examines its subject matter while maintaining song-like musical qualities. Unlike pure praise or celebration typical of traditional songs and odes, the evaluative song incorporates critical judgment, weighing merits and flaws, or offering measured assessment. This form combines lyric beauty with analytical perspective, creating verse that thinks as well as feels. The evaluation may concern aesthetic objects, experiences, ideas, people, or cultural phenomena. The form demonstrates poetry's capacity for critical thought within musical structure, proving that song need not abandon judgment for beauty or sacrifice aesthetic pleasure for intellectual rigor.
Example
Example in poetry:
Traditional ballads like “Barbara Allen” function as evaluative songs judging love and death; Bob Dylan’s “Masters of War” evaluates militarism; Gil Scott-Heron’s “The Revolution Will Not Be Televised” evaluates media complacency; Nina Simone’s “Mississippi Goddam” evaluates racial violence; Kendrick Lamar’s “Alright” evaluates hope amid oppression; contemporary protest poets like Danez Smith use evaluative song in performance.
Additional Notes
An Evaluative song assesses a person, event, or idea through lyrical reflection—blends narrative with judgment, common in folk or commemorative poetry.
Also Known As
Critical lyric Judging ode Appraising verse Critical ode
Skip to main content