Home › Glossary › Letter S

Subjective interpretation fallacy

Concept
Pronunciation

Understanding ARPABET Pronunciation

Want to hear it? Click the Listen button to hear the browser speak the word using text-to-speech!

The pronunciation guide uses the ARPABET phonetic system—the same system used in speech recognition and text-to-speech applications.

Vowel Examples:
AE1 = cat, bat
EH1 = bed, head
IY1 = see, me
OW1 = go, boat
UW1 = boot, do
Stress Numbers:
0 = no stress (unstressed)
1 = primary stress (loud)
2 = secondary stress (medium)
Example:
AH0 TH IY1 N AH0
= a-THEE-na (Athena)

The stressed syllable (marked with 1) is pronounced louder and clearer than others.

Quick Definition

The error of overvaluing personal emotional reaction when interpreting poetry

Detailed Definition
The subjective interpretation fallacy occurs when a reader assumes that a poem’s meaning is solely determined by personal emotional response, disregarding textual evidence, historical context, or authorial intent; while reader-response theory values individual engagement, this fallacy neglects the poem as a crafted artifact with internal logic, leading to misreadings that conflate the speaker’s voice with the poet’s or ignore formal constraints shaping meaning.
Example
Example in poetry:
Subjective interpretation fallacy assumes the poet’s intent equals reader response: Claiming “The Road Not Taken” is about individualism ignores Frost’s ironic tone; Assuming Sylvia Plath’s “Daddy” is literal autobiography rather than symbolic; Reading “Ode on a Grecian Urn” as purely about beauty without considering its epistemological questions; Insisting a poem “means” only what the reader feels, disregarding textual evidence.
Additional Notes
Subjective interpretation fallacy|The mistaken belief that any reading of a poem is equally valid, ignoring constraints of the text, historical context, or authorial intent; contrasts with close reading and textual evidence.
Also Known As
Affective fallacy Reader-response misstep Subjective fallacy
Skip to main content