Public Poem Comments

Showing 31 to 40 of 40 comments (Page 2 of 2)

Neutral Tones

(2025-06-26 10:06)

What an evocative line: "The smile on your mouth was the deadest thing / Alive enough to have strength to die;" No wonder Hardy is one of our greatest poets. I love this poem and I love the musical arrangements. 8 to choose from! You spoil us, truely you do.

0

Property of Pigeons

(2025-06-26 08:30)

"as if an angel had been sick" - one of my favourite lines in a poem.

0
1 reply
"Thank you for your comment, Maggie. That line stands out for me as well: it manages to be both start..."Richard

Brancusi’s Golden Bird

(2025-06-26 08:27)

A musical interpretation of a poem interpreting a work of art. Interesting. Thank you for introducing me to this poet. I had never heard of Mina Loy before today.

0
1 reply
"Thank you for your thoughtful comment. I am glad you found the idea of layering musical interpretati..."Richard

A Sense of Humor

(2025-06-25 11:27)

Sense of humor indeed will keep us floating through this turbulent sea of life. What a magnificent performance to a powerful poem!

0
1 reply
"Thank you so much for your thoughtful comment! I couldn’t agree more; humor really is a lifeboat in ..."Richard

Wind on the Hill

(2025-06-25 11:11)

Very beautiful! The track 2 successfully captures the whimsical and quizzical nature of the poem. Track 1 is amazing too!

0
1 reply
"Thank you so much for your kind words! I’m delighted that you enjoyed both tracks and that the whims..."Richard
(2025-06-21 12:17)

What a wonderful experience! I’ve always loved “Wind on the Hill,” but hearing it brought to life with those hypnotic Afrobeats rhythms gave the poem a whole new dimension. This arrangement is both playful and deeply moving. Thank you for sharing such a creative and joyful interpretation!

0
1 reply
"Thank you so much, Maggie! I’m thrilled you enjoyed these arrangements—“Wind on the Hill” has always..."Richard

O, that this too too solid flesh would melt

(2025-06-24 22:08)

I love the word-play where William says: "O, that this too too solid flesh would melt, Thaw and resolve itself into a dew!" where the play on words of "a dew" and "adieu" are so obvious but perhaps so overlooked. Maybe the audience of the day would have got the joke?

0
1 reply
"That's quite an observation. "a dew" - "adieu" - Thank you for pointing this out."Richard

Rooks (II)

(2025-06-23 12:39)

I don’t know much about music, but I know what I like and I really loved this! The song made me feel a bit sad and hopeful at the same time. The singing and guitar sound kind of mysterious, and it all fits the poem so well. I liked how the music made the words feel alive, almost like what the poem says about living on through words really happened here. It’s beautiful and moving. Thank you for sharing it!

0

O Ailing Love

(2025-06-23 08:20)

What a profoundly moving experience! "O Ailing Love" is such a powerful meditation on the decline and impermanence of passion; Millay’s imagery of love as a wounded bird, once majestic but now earthbound, is both haunting and beautiful. The poem’s resigned melancholy and its final vision of the fading swans linger long after reading, capturing the bittersweet complexity of letting go. The musical arrangement elevates this emotional journey even further. The beautiful female vocalist brings out every nuance of longing and acceptance in Millay’s words, her voice full of tenderness and quiet strength. Listening to her performance, I felt the poem’s sorrow and grace as if they were my own. This is a breathtakingly emotional and beautiful interpretation. Thank you for creating such a memorable experience.

0
1 reply
"Your reflection on "O Ailing Love" captures exactly what draws me to Millay's work: her ability to t..."Richard

The Stormy Petrel

(2025-06-22 21:20)

Absolutely brilliant! Those driving reggaeton rhythms instantly pulled me in. The hypnotic beats and staccato desert blues guitar create such a unique atmosphere. This arrangement is both adventurous and uplifting. What a fantastic way to bring this lovely poem to life!

1
1 reply
"Thanks for sharing your thoughts on the arrangement. I’m pleased the reggaeton rhythms and desert bl..."Richard